Haley Reinhart sparkly shoes on American Idol Top 3

I received an email request to help identify the sparkling silver peep toe platform heels Haley wore on the American Idol Top 3 show on 5/18/11.  First, I must say, I was really sorry to see Haley get voted off this week because that girl has some killer pipes and great style to boot.  I’m sure she has a bright music career ahead of her though — shiny and bright like the shoes she wore in one of her looks from the Top 3 show (pictured above).  Haley donned a pair of sparkle pumps for her performance of the Fleetwood Mac song “Rhiannon” and, while these shoes do appear to have a dark silver uppper, possibly in glitter, I’m thinking that this black sequin pair is likely the one she wore:

This is the Guess Hondola 2, which is a style that has been released in several color options and has the same side cutouts, side buckle and black platform as Haley’s shoes.  And, as you can see in the stock photo, the sequins appear to reflect in silver and this effect is likely magnified under those bright American Idol lights, which might be why it appears to be more of a pewter color on the show.  Of course, it’s also possible that there is (or will be) a dark silver version of this pair, but I don’t see it available in this color right now.

You can find this shoe for $99 with free overnight shipping at Endless.  If you’d rather get your sparkle on in a different color, this pair also comes in blue sequins, gold glitter, silver sequins and a black glitter version with silver glitter platform, each for the same price (some options have free 2-day shipping rather than overnight).

Have a great weekend!

Update 5/23/11:  I also received some questions about Haley’s white platform shoes worn on the Top 3 results show.  After doing some digging, I found out that the shoes (pictured above) are custom designed by a shoe designer who goes by Ms. Misha on Twitter (@4MiShA).  I’m glad to be able to see these shoes up close and, wow, they are gorgeous!  If you want to find out more information, there is an email address listed on her Twitter page where you can contact her.

Haley photo from

P.S. Be a friend of Fairy Shoe Princess on Facebook!


6 Responses to “Haley Reinhart sparkly shoes on American Idol Top 3”

  1. Ellie Says:

    nice! now what about the dress? haha… anyone have a source on that?

  2. Fairy Shoe Princess Says:

    Hi Ellie! According to Stylelist, the dress is by Tony Cohen:

  3. Kelly Says:

    OMG!!! I knew I loved them! And I could only see the toes!!! I need to learn how to make shoes. WANT!!!!

  4. Fairy Shoe Princess Says:

    I agree, they are amazing!! Maybe you could contact the designer to see what they go for!

  5. Ms. Misha Says:

    Hi, I am Ms.Misha. I custom designed the white pair of shoes for Haley. for all inquiries, please email me at

  6. Fairy Shoe Princess Says:

    Thanks for stopping by Ms. Misha! We appreciate the info. :)

Leave a Reply

© 2018 The Fairy Shoe Princess.
Site design by Just Spiffy Web Design